In Our Little Secret, Lindsay Lohan continues her return to the rom-com spotlight with a tale that embodies the spirit of holiday romance. Directed by Stephen Herek, the film brings together festive charm and family drama, creating a cozy yet predictable addition to Netflix’s seasonal catalog.
Lohan’s portrayal of Avery, a woman navigating an awkward reunion with her ex during Christmas, showcases her ability to anchor a story, even when the narrative doesn’t offer much originality.
A Premise Full of Potential
The central plot revolves around Avery and her ex, Cameron, reuniting at his family’s holiday gathering. Their decision to keep their past relationship a secret sets the stage for comedic moments and awkward misunderstandings. While the premise promises screwball humor and heartfelt reconciliation, the execution leans heavily on well-worn rom-com tropes, resulting in a story that feels more comfortable than innovative.
Festive Atmosphere, Familiar Formula
One undeniable strength of Our Little Secret is its holiday atmosphere. From twinkling lights to a picturesque family home, the film captures the visual appeal of Christmas. However, the story unfolds in a manner that feels overly familiar, sticking closely to the formula of seasonal rom-coms.
Moments of humor, such as a weed-gummy mishap or a church singalong, often feel forced rather than genuinely funny, leaving little that stands out.
Supporting Cast Steals the Spotlight
While the central romance struggles to find its footing, the supporting cast injects energy and eccentricity into the film. Kristin Chenoweth’s over-the-top matriarch and Henry Czerny’s warm, understated father provide some of the movie’s most memorable moments.
Their performances help to elevate the material, even as the script remains rooted in predictability.
A Safe, Cozy Choice
Our Little Secret is a quintessential holiday rom-com: warm, lighthearted, and easy to watch. While it doesn’t break new ground or offer particularly memorable moments, it serves its purpose as a comforting, festive escape. Lindsay Lohan’s continued presence in the genre reinforces her status as a rom-com favorite, even if the film itself doesn’t quite match her star power.
Watch the Our Little Secret (2024) Trailer
This movie is ideal for casual holiday viewing, perfect for enjoying while wrapping gifts or sipping hot cocoa. However, those looking for a standout addition to the Christmas movie canon may find it lacking in originality and emotional depth. Still, as part of Lohan’s ongoing renaissance, it’s another reminder of her charm and ability to carry a rom-com with effortless appeal.
